DETECTION OF DIATOMS IN NON-DROWNING CASES - A POST-MORTEM STUDY
Keywords:
Diatom, Diatom test, Non-drowned deaths, Diagnosis, ReliabilityAbstract
Diatom test was thought to be gold standard in diagnosis and confirmation of drowning related deaths. Besides determination of cause of death, it also helps to deduce the site of drowning. However, since detection of diatoms in the lung fields of non-drowned deaths in workers of kieshelgur industries by Otto H in the year 1961, many workers claimed that diatoms were also found in lung as well as other peripheral organs in non-drowned individuals, raising serious doubt about the reliability and utility of diatom test. Many of strong supporters of diatom test still rely upon it and attributed presence of diatoms in non-drowned deaths to post-mortem contaminations. Amid controversy surrounding the diatom test, the present study conducted over 750 different tissues from 150 non-drowned deaths using Nitric acid digestion method, diatoms could be detected in 27(18%) cases and 49 (6.53%) different tissues. Small sizes pinnate shaped diatoms were mostly found in liver, kidney, brain and bone marrow tissues where as both small and large sizes diatoms were found in lung tissues.
References
Revenstorf V. Der Nachweis der aspirierten Ertrankungs flussigkeit des Todes dutch Ertrinken, Vierteljabressebs Geritchtl Med Off. Sanitaaetswes. 1904;28: 274-9
Otto H. Uber den Nachweis von Diatoeen in menschlichen Lungenstauben. Frankf. Z. Pathol. 1961;71: 176-81
Mueller B. On the problems of the occurrence of diatoms in the organs of cadavers not having lain in water. Deutsche Z. Ges. Gerichtl. Med. 1963; 54: 267- 272.
Spitz WU, Schneider V. The significance of diatoms in the diagnosis of death by drowning. J.For Sci. 1964; 9 (1): 11-8
Porawski R. Investigation on the occurrence of diatoms in organs in death from various causes. J. For Med. 1966; 13: 134-87
Koseki, T. (1968) ‘Fundamental examination of experimental materials and control animals on the diagnosis of death from drowning by the diatom method’. Acta Med. Boil. 1967; 15: 207-19
Neidhart DA, Grrendyke RM. The significance of diatom demonstrations in the diagnosis of death by drowning. Amer J. Clin Path; 48(4): 377-82
Schneider V. Evaluation of the diatom test. Beltr Gerichtz Med. 1969; 26: 92-99
Timperman J. Medico-legal problems in death by drowning: Its diagnosis by the diatom method. Journal of Forensic Medicine. 1969; 16 (2): 45-75
Schellmann B, Sperl W. Diotomeen Nachweis im Knochenmark (femur) Nichtertrunkener. Z. rechtsmed. 1979; 83: 319-24
Calder IM. An evaluation of the diatom test in deaths of professional divers. Med Sci Law. 1984; 24(1): 41-46
Pollanen MS. Forensic Diatomology and Drowning. Elsevier Publication. 1998.
Thomas F, Hecke VW, Timperman J. The detection of diatoms in the bone marrow as evidence of death by drowning. J. For Med.1961; 8(3): 142-44.
Hendey NI. The diagnostic value of diatoms in case of drowning. Med Sci Law. 1973; 13: 23-24
Peabody AJ. Diatoms and Drowning- A Review. Med. Sci. Law. 1980; 20 (4): 254-61.
Foged N. Diatoms and Drowning-Once More. For Sci Int. 1983; 21: 153-59
Schneider V. Über den Beweiswert von Diatomeen in den Organen des grossen Kreislaufs als Zeichen des Ertrinkungstodes. Med Thesis, Berlin. 1965
Tabbara W, Derobert L. [Technical note on the diatoms]. Ann Med Leg Criminol Police Sci Toxicol. 1962; 42: 613–615.
Gunatilake PGL, Gooneratne I. Drowning Associated Diatoms In Sri Lanka. Sri Lanka Journal of Forensic Medicine, Science & Law. 2010; Vol.1 No.2 p. 24.
Yen LY, Jayaprakash PT. Prevalence of diatom frustules in non-vegetarian foodstuffs and its implications in interpreting identification of diatom frustules in drowning cases. Forensic Sci Int. 2007 Jul 20; 170(1): 1-7.
Merli S, Durante F, Umani, Ronchi GU. Sul valore diagnostico del reperto di diatomee negli organi degli annegati. Zacchia. 1964; 27: 516–532.
Tomonaga T. Identification of death by drowning by the disorganization method (diatom method). Acta med Nagasaki. 1960; 5: 116–125.
Hurlimann J, Feer P, Elber F, Niederberger K, Dirnhofer R, Wyler D. Diatom detection in the diagnosis of death by drowning. Int. J. Leg Med. 2000; 114: 6-14
Pachar JV, Cameron JM. The diagnosis of drowning by quantitative and qualitative diatom analysis. Med Sci Law. 1993; 33(4): 291-99
Giri BS, Tripathi CB, Chowdary YB. Characterization of drowning by diatom test. Indian J Med Res. 1993; 98: 40-43.
Auer A. Qualitative diatom analysis as a tool to diagnose drowning. Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 1991; 12, 213-218.
Timpermann J. The diagnosis of drowning- a review. Journal of Forensic Science. 1972; 1: 397-409.
Ludes B, Coste M. Diatomées et médecine légale. Technique et Documentation, Lavoisier, Paris. 1996.
Waltz H. Zur Beweiskraft von Diatomeenbefunden. Aktuelle Fragen der Gerichtlichen Medizin. Wiss Zschr Martin-Luther-Univ, Halle-Wittenberg (Sonderheft). 1965.
Janitzki V. Zur Frage der Sicherheit des Diatomeen Nachweises. Arch Kriminol. 1964; 134, 24–25.
Polson CJ, Gee DJ, Knight B. The Essentials of Forensic Medicine. Pergamon press. 4th ed., 1985; p 434.
Tsokos M. Macroscpical, Microscopical, and Laboratory Findings in Drowning Victims. Forensic Pathology Reviews. Humana Press. 2005; Vol. 3, pp 3-77
